A Provisional Reporting Completeness Index for Honey Sample Preparation and Its Pilot Application
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.70882/3xbkkv55Keywords:
AGREEprep, Reporting Completeness, Sample Preparation, Green Analytical Chemistry, Reporting CompletenessAbstract
Reporting completeness and environmental greenness are distinct properties of analytical methods. This study developed a provisional ten-domain Reporting Completeness Index for honey sample preparation (RCI-Honey) and applied a 0–2 documentary rubric to four purposively selected publications. Source reconciliation yielded scores of 60% for Guo, 60% for Lasheras, 90% for Casado, and 75% for Lupu (mean 71.25%; median 67.5%). Workflow and sample transfers were consistently documented; waste, energy, and occupational-safety information was less complete. Sixteen alternative coding scenarios produced a mean range of 70–75%, without changing the two highest-ranked studies. Only two potentially matched AGREEprep assessments were available, so no inferential correlation was estimated. RCI-Honey provides an auditable description of reporting within the reviewed evidence boundary, not a validated measure of greenness or reproducibility. Independent coding, external content review, and a larger corpus are required before broader use.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences (Science Forum)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.


